Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Sarasota, FL & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Sarasota, FL

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
Nationwide A+ 8.2%
Erie A+ 7.02%
State Farm A 6.9%
Allstate A+ 4.9%
Liberty Mutual A 3.2%

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Wagner Insurance Group Llc 7250 Ulmerton Rd., Ste. G
33771
West Virginia Insurance Agency 5104 N Lockwood Ridge Rd #104
34243
Kelly Insurance Agency Inc 1000 S BELCHER RD SUITE 3
www.kellyins.com 33771
727-507-7525
Email:info@kellyins.com
Simpkins Foley Insurance Associates 8870 N Himes Ave 8870 N Himes Ave Tampa
www.simpkinsinsuranceagency.com 33614
Strachan Insurance Agency Inc. 421 A Commercial Court
34292
Fabey Insurance Agency 5783 Beneva Rd
34233
(941) 923-7515
Hinkle Insurance Agency Inc. 83 PARK PL BLVD STE 101
33759
727-461-6044
Short Pump Insurance Llc 230 Tamiami Trl S Ste 31
34285
Cta Insurance Agency Inc. 3704 Swann Avenue
33609-4522
813-289-7888
Linwood Forest Insurance Group Llc 4404 N TAMIAMI TRAIL
www.linwoodforest.com 34234
941-360-6777

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
William Edwards 4130 Woodmere Park Blvd. Suite 9
34293
(941) 882-5765
Brady Krebs 12008 E Mlk Blvd
33584-4917
813-653-1560
Charles Fritz 8120 4th St N Frnt
33702-3629
727-576-8200
Tommy Sugg 3815 Us Hwy 301 N
34222
Sims-Thaxton 11401 Seminole Blvd
33778
Horton & Assoc Llc 1315 PROVIDENCE RD
33511
813-681-9884
Bayou Insurance Services Of Louisiana 4342 Duhme Rd
33708-2809
727-391-3422
Michael J Mcdyer 2703 West Kennedy Boulevard
33609
(813) 259-1142
Ekalaka Ins Agy 5700 4th St N
33703
(727) 526-9041
Finn & Stone 8243 US Highway 301 N
34219
(941) 722-6678

Top state farm Home Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
John Hilleyer 8209 Natures Way Unit 203C Lakewood\u00a0Ranch
34202

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Kelly Garland 100 NORTH INDIAN ROCKS RD
33770
800-891-4222
Chuck Petretti 3224 W Kennedy Blvd
33609-3007
813-879-7808
Timothy Martin 1070 Kapp Dr
33765
Jason Sardi 992 TAMIAMI TRAIL UNIT E2
33953
941-889-7836
Jason Tateishi 100 VENICE AVE W SUITE K
34285
941-483-3999
Jason Tansey 270 S TAMIAMI TRAIL
34285
941-493-1583
Don Dvorak 11009 Gatewood Dr Ste 104
34211
(941) 927-8311
Crystal Rios 2269 Tamiami Trail S
34293-5067
941-497-4422
Todd Reus Lutcf 3607 W Waters Ave
33614
Chase Giossi 5051 Memorial Hwy
33634-7355
813-243-1300

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Doyle Miles & Sokol 13015 Tamiami Trl
34287
(941) 423-1686
Teddy J Byrd Agency 555 E Ave
34285
Dennis Charles Oneill 21554 Angela Ln
34293
(941) 493-5808
Ilma Inc. 505 WESTBROOK AVE
33511
813-685-8040
Lofton Wells Llc 5665 CENTRAL AVE
33710
727-344-5500
Mitchell Agency Inc The 1812 MANATEE AVE W
34205
941-748-1812
Chester T Zentz Iii 305 N 6th Ave
33873-2319
863-773-6100
Denise Sullivan Clement Agency 1807 Englewood Rd
34223
(941) 475-7778
Lohr Ins Services Inc 8831 49TH ST N STE 1
33782
727-327-1290
Kelly Ins Services Llc 1212 CLEVELAND ST
33755
727-446-9116

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Sarasota, FL

ErieLiberty MutualNationwide
Median Home Value ($) 245,290235,290205,290
Construction year 197219682008
Home Coverage ($) $350000-$400000$200000-$250000$200000-$250000
Total Premium ($) $5184$3229$3764

Sarasota, FL Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Erie upto 18%
Allstate upto 23%
Liberty Mutual upto 16%
Nationwide upto 11%